I thought I would take a fast look at this, originally prepared as background to an 'Introduction to Experimental Archaeology' course I was auditing in the fall. *
https://ourworldindata.org/human-height
Is by far the most complete look at this overall. It is weighted towards
modern (last 50) with some data for the last 200 years.
Historically - and into modern times, males run about 4 inches average
taller than females
But down into the centre, there is information based historically. There
is a lack of fine detail. You do have to look at a number of the
overviews and try to pull them together.
* Generally the view is global, so often there is no break down
outside of a European average
* A lot of the charts don't have enough resolution - 5 cm is the usual
indicated variations.
* Scandinavian countries do have higher protein in basic diet. Body
sizes increase.
* Denmark shows as the clear largest body size (even to modern times)
There appears to be a relatively stable size (with dips from war /
famine) over the last 2000 years. With a slight *drop* over the
beginnings of the Industrial Revolution (rural to urban?). Then a sharp
increase over the last 50 years especially (this is world wide too).
For the Norse
http://www.vikinganswerlady.com/vikheight.shtml
by Else Roesdahl:
"The examination of skeletons from different localities in
Scandinavia reveals that the average height of the Vikings was a
little less than that of today: men were about 5 ft 7-3/4 in. tall
and women 5 ft 2-1/2 in.
Don't let Carolyn's seeming casual presentation throw you. I have known
her for years and her work is always well researched.
I found this paper - which I have only very quickly scanned
http://www.j-bradford-delong.net/articles_of_the_month/pdf/w8542.pdf
Again the focus here is the impact of urbanization / Industrial Revolution.
There is some back reference into the Middle Ages (check his table 2 -
at the bottom)
Based on skeletons, it looks like the quote is
Britian 1200 = 168 cm
Norway 1200 = 170 cm
Sweden 1100 - 1200 = 172 cm
Not enough samples for the UK - but it does look like 2 - 4 cm differences
There is a SHARP decrease in body size from the later 1700's through to
the late 1800s !!
Body sizes during the actual Medieval period (500 - 1500) seem fairly
stable (short localized drops)
Note that effective 'striking range' for a sword is effectively : 4 cm
Body height equals arm length
Larger body equals increased 'ideal' blade control size
(So this effect can be doubled!)
So, I was certainly a bit on the high side for average Scandinavians,
also under estimated UK a bit.
(my own height is 175 cm / 70 inches)
Not the best data - but at least an idea
PS - to my regular readers :
You would have noticed a sharp drop off in posts over the last several months. This is partially due to a lot of back and forth for the course mentioned. I have been working on a number of more detailed research and writing projects - some likely too detailed to break up and post here.
Stay tuned however (expect some notes on Viking Age knives, historic metalworking )
Sunday, December 22, 2019
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment